Director presenting an executive pitch across a boardroom table to a CFO and senior leadership team

Why I Had an Answer for Every Objection Except the One That Mattered

I walked into the meeting with an answer for every objection. Ten minutes in, the CFO asked a question I couldn’t answer.

She asked “How does this investment help us achieve the financial commitments we’ve already made to the board?” I had prepared for every objection I could imagine about my initiative, but I didn’t really understand the commitments she had made or the pressures she was facing.

Directors walk into a similar moment all the time, ready to defend their team’s work while the executive leadership team (ELT) is looking at the company as a whole.

Today I’ll share four questions to answer before your next pitch, so you can avoid the mistake I made.

Let’s start with what that CFO could see that I couldn’t.

What the CFO saw

The CFO was accountable for a budget and financial plan she and the ELT had agreed to meet.

From her seat, the issue was obvious. From mine, it was invisible. I had come in to win for my project. She was looking for a win for the whole company.

Every person on the executive leadership team hears your pitch through their own concerns. Find those out first.

The head of operations is thinking about what her teams already have on their plates. The head of sales is thinking about satisfying customers and growing revenue. Each one is doing the job they’re measured on, and your proposal either helps with that job or adds to it.

The four questions below help you prepare for the people in the room, along with the idea.

Four questions to answer before your next pitch

1. Who decides, and who do they listen to?

List everyone who will have a say, including the people outside the room whose opinion the executives trust. A finance partner or a chief of staff can shape a decision without ever commenting on a slide.

2. What is each of them accountable for?

Executive teams are judged on a short list of measures: revenue growth, margin, customer satisfaction, market share, operational risk, and strategic advantage. Each executive owns a piece of that list, as a team they own it all. Write down which piece belongs to each person and how your proposal moves it. If you can put a rough number and a date on it, do.

3. What would make each of them hesitate?

This is the question you can’t answer alone. Ask each person before the meeting:

What concerns do you have?

What could go wrong?

What would you need to see to support this?

Their answers will tell you more than any amount of preparation at your desk.

4. How does your proposal answer each concern, and what shows you can deliver?

Build the answers into the proposal itself, so each executive hears their concern addressed before they raise it. Your team’s track record belongs here. It’s the proof that you can deliver what you’re promising.

How that pitch would have gone

Here is my presentation to that CFO, replayed with the four questions answered first.

Who decides?

The initiative needed its share of limited capital, so the CFO had real say over whether this moved forward or not. I had treated her as one more person in the audience.

What is she accountable for?

How both opex and capex move across the whole portfolio, and ensuring our investment and spending created the financial outcomes we needed. My initiative was competing with everything else that needed money that year.

What would make her hesitate?

The marginal ROI and financial risk. If I had sat down with her before the meeting and asked what concerns she had, she would have told me exactly what she told everyone in that room.

How does the proposal answer it?

I could have phased the spending to fit the enterprise outcomes we needed and opened the presentation with that.

In that version, the CFO’s concern would have been answered on the first slide. She would have already helped shape the plan, so she would have every reason to support it.

I also wouldn’t stop with the CFO. I would have had the same one-on-one conversation with the head of operations, the head of sales, and anyone else with a say. By the time the meeting started, each of them would have heard the proposal and helped shape it, and the meeting would be about making the decision.

From the dance floor to the balcony

The four questions take you off the dance floor, where you can only see your own project, and up to the balcony, where you can see what everyone in the room is concerned with. The leaders who move up are the ones who make that climb before every important pitch. You go to the balcony and invite your colleagues to join you there, so you can see the bigger picture, together.

What comes next

The four questions tell you what to find out. Getting honest answers takes practice, especially from senior people who have learned to keep their cards close to the vest.

That’s the work we do in Stakeholder Breakthrough, the workshop I teach. You build a Stakeholder Map for your own initiative: a strategic game plan that shows who has a say, what they care about or fear, and who influences whom, so you know who to talk to and in what order. Then you practice the one-on-one conversations that bring out what people really think, and plan how to walk into a decision-making meeting with the support already earned.

If you have a proposal coming up that needs several people to say yes, join the waitlist for the next session.

Transform Your Leadership.
Transform Your Team.
Achieve Your Vision.

Join senior leaders receiving practical strategies on stakeholder buy-in, culture change, and organizational momentum. Delivered straight to your inbox.

Short reads. Immediate application. Unsubscribe in one click.

Author Bio:

Michael Papanek – A Leadership Coach, Executive Advisor, OD Consultant, Author, and Team Facilitator

Michael Papanek, a professional leadership coach and expert team consultant, has an interesting backstory. Brought up in a family of leadership and teamwork experts, he has followed in the footsteps of the “family business”. Over 30 years of practice, Michael has developed a uniquely satisfying ability to describe interpersonal and cultural principles blending creative flair with extensive experience, which leads to sustained performance improvement when applied by his clients in real life.

Contact E-mail: michael@michaelpapanek.com

Transform Your Leadership - Transform Your Team - Achieve Your Vision

Subscribe to receive insights on achieving breakthrough results through cultural intelligence, strategic leadership and agile innovation—practical ideas you can use in your next meeting to lead your organization through transformation and change.

Join our community of change-makers, culture leaders and creators to build the team and the career you deserve.

Make your pivotal business relationships unbreakable

From Breakdown to Breakthrough is your playbook to build resilient business relationships that stand up to the heat of change.

“Ultimate decoder ring for rising professionals”
“Well-written, thoughtful account of how to develop and lead teams.”
”A game changer for business relationships”